Why She Stayed! (The child’s perspective!) #whyistayed

MY VIEWS | | September 11, 2014 at 7:59 am

In light of the whole #whyistayed #whyileft discussion I wanted to add my own story, from a child’s point of view. I’m sure my sisters and some members of my family would want to disown me for writing this but the shame has to stop on the victims. This is my tale to tell and boy am I telling it.

Growing up I never had a lot of respect for my mom’s decisions. I loved her to bits and she was my favorite person in the world but I felt anyone who remained married to my dad could not have been too smart. I thought she was weak, how else would you explain being married to a man that beat you up? The issues were complicated of course, (aren’t they always?) but to me it was pretty clear leaving him was the best thing to do. I spent several times either behind a closed door, or under the kitchen table, doing nothing to help as blows and yelling permeated the air. My 9 year old self was drenched in the stench of helplessness and guilt (for doing nothing). I was scared but I still wonder what would have happened had I spoken up. Not that I had never felt the wrath of his violence, all my sisters did, but I was honestly terrified.

Days of rushing from school (over 30 minute walk away – the concept of school buses did not exist) just to make sure I could feed my mom laying in bed sore from the aftermath. Dealing with the stares as the scars to the face could not be hidden like the ones on the rest of the body, meant we stayed isolated. In retrospect that worked out better for my dad than anyone else. Why did she not leave? In fairness she did try once, no twice and almost the 3rd time. The 1st was to go to her parent’s home 3 hours away. Her parents sent her back telling her to apologize to him. The stigma of shame having their daughter at their home was greater than the darkened scars from the bruising on her face. I have no idea how they could pretend the scars did not exist. I lost all my respect for them that time. My grandfather told me I should tell my dad what he was doing was wrong and tell him to stop. Me? A child? To go in between the blows and kicks to rationally tell him to stop? I recall me telling him not to put me in the beach water once and I had a bloody mouth to show for it. No. Way!

She went back. I mean if your parents don’t provide you shelter in a community that loved him for all the gifts he showered on them, where could she go? One night I recall being awakened by her asking us to put our shoes on. It was apparent a fight had been going on. Then my dad drew his gun, oh licensed you see – BECAUSE EVEN LICENSED GUN OWNERS CAN DO SHITTY THINGS ARMED WITH A GUN (thank you Starbucks and Panera for your stand on guns on your premises). Of course the gun won. Fear wins when your husband threatens you to go but leave the kids. How on earth could she do that?

Then my home burned down in political riots, along with the rest of our town (this was in an Apartheid South Africa). Best thing to happen to us ever! Oh, I really mean that. Now my mom could get exposed to more people and the seclusion would end. In the whirlwind of applying for food grants after the unrest available to refugees my mom secretly started talking to social workers. My sisters were in school later (I was 12 at this time) and I was walking with my mom alone when she confided in me that she was looking for support to leave my dad. It was then that I uttered the most selfish of words. The words that haunt me forever. I asked “What about us?” She KNEW he would never allow us to go to her. Ever! Maybe I was too young to understand the power of my words or not smart enough to take them back but that plan died there on that long road back. The beatings continued. He was a master of hiding his Jerkyl and Hyde personality.

A year later he died. Just like that. A heart attack, collapsed and died in a parking lot. Suddenly a future I could never see for any of us now was there. I did not mourn him. We did the rituals like any person in the community expected but inside me it was a ritual of joy. Liberation tasted good. The future was going to be tough but it was ours. The guilt I carried stayed with me and I went on to study and become and engineer and vowed to make every one of my mom’s spoken and unspoken wishes come true. I understood. I understood why it was so hard to leave. I understood if she had support she would have been helped. I saw the looks that people gave her “She must have done something to deserve that!” and I wondered why no-one judged him.

I would never be able to be the person who stayed with someone like that but I would never assume leaving was so easy.  Save the pity and stop judging people.

27 Comments

  1. 1
    Lindsay says:

    THANK YOU for sharing your experience. I am so glad you, your sisters, and your mom were liberated, though it took some time. The home and the family you have created for you and your daughters is so opposite of what you describe, and I’m so, so happy you are here with us to live it. Love to you and yours.

  2. 2
    Gina says:

    Nirasha, What an incredibly brave story to tell. Thank you for sharing your point of view as a child involved and to show why a woman may make the choices she does. I appreciate your willingness to make public such a personal story in order to raise awareness and the need for us as women to support each other rather than to judge. Thank you again! Gina

  3. 3
    IlinaP says:

    I am floored and touched and proud of you for sharing this tough story. I love you more than ever.

  4. 4
    Ellen G says:

    Such an amazing story. You must be passing that strength onto your girls every day. Showing them that they are loved, that they matter, will inform the decisions they make in their lives.

  5. 5
    Robin Rue says:

    Thank you so much for sharing this story. As adults, it’s hard to understand how a child looks at a situation like that, but you’re first hand experience really puts a whole different spin on it.

  6. 6

    I read this 3 times. Thank you for sharing these incredible, powerful and honestly raw words. These words are the kind of words that will change someone’s life. You are a wonderful woman Niri… strong, brave and powerful. xo

  7. 7
    Kate Hayes says:

    Wow…Niri, I had no idea that this happened in your childhood. I knew you grew up during Apartheid, but didn’t realize that the depths of your “survivor” spirit went even deeper than that. Now I am even more amazed by you. This view of domestic abuse from a child’s perspective is so powerful and I’m sure it will help many people to read it. Thank you so much for sharing your story.

  8. 8

    I love you so much. Thank you for being so brave and honest and for being a voice for so many

  9. 9
    Mom of Two says:

    I am a mother of two girls who has just left her husband after 6 years of abuse. I can understand why your mother didn’t leave. I have to answer questions of my girls when she asks me everyday why we can’t be with dad and it is not easy. I do not really understand what to tell her.
    You are so lucky that your dad passed away.

  10. 10
    Jennie says:

    Thank you for sharing this, and letting others know they are a) not alone, and b) leaving isn’t always as easy as it sounds. I grew up in a household like yours. Things got particularly bad after my nana passed away. Her house was our safe haven, and it was suddenly gone. I was only seven. It took seven years after that before my mother finally had the courage to leave. For her, she grew up without a father, and always felt that it was better to make it work than have her children fatherless.

    I remember the day I called her at work (she was a cashier at a supermarket), to tell her my sister pulled a knife on my dad to protect herself. He was in a drunken rage, and she wasn’t going to stand for one more beating. That’s what it finally took for her to throw him out. My mother has been my hero in many ways, as well as a reminder of what I don’t want my life to ever be like. As I try to figure out life without my husband, I remind myself that three years and eight years with an incredible father and role model was an incredible gift.

  11. 11

    Oh wow. Niri, this must have been so hard to write. The issues surrounding domestic abuse are so complicated. I am just so happy you and your family found freedom. Thank you for sharing this. The victims do need to be heard and the shaming needs to stop.

  12. 12
    Beth B. says:

    Wow – very powerful post and you are so brave for sharing your story. I am sure you are inspiring to others in that situation. It is important to get the discussion going online.

  13. 13
    Shelley says:

    Thank you for sharing your story.

  14. 14
    Deanna U says:

    Thanks for recounting and sharing. I often wonder what it is like to grow up in an environment as such. I love your courage and hopefully people will understand that this is real, not just TV.

  15. 15
    Vera Sweeney says:

    Wow Niri – tears. Raw and open and honest. I thank you for your courage. And I owe you a hug the next time I see you. And a Starbucks too actually

  16. 16
    Isra says:

    Tears and a heavy heart. I can’t imagine how hard this was for you to write. Your spirit is so bright, I would never have guessed it came from something so dark. Love you friend.

  17. 17
    Nancy Dussault Smith says:

    Wow. Thank you for sharing your story, for going back to that dark place and time and allowing yourself to so truthfully express your feelings. You are a strong woman and an inspiration. Sending you hugs.

  18. 18
    Desaree says:

    It was the same in my family growing up. My mom would take us to my aunts house for a few days when things would blow up and we’d think, oh this time its for good. But she’d always bring us back and it would start all over again. I always thought she was weak too. I just didnt understand how you can let a man do that to you AND to your children and not do anything to stop it. My mom turned off her emotions when she married him. He is my stepdad. For years I thought she didnt love me. Then I read an article the other day that some women in abusive relationships turn off their emotions to deal with their existence and that when they do that they have trouble turning their emotions back on towards their children. It explained everything for me and I feel so much better having read that.

  19. 19

    Wow. I can’t imagine the physical beatings and the scars, but the domestic disturbance? I totally get it. In fact, on numerous occasions, my sister and I asked when we would leave. We were lucky it wasn’t our dad, but it took many years of asking.

    I have since forgiven, but it’s not easy. And, I can honestly say if he would have dropped dead while we were there, I wouldn’t have been sad for a minute.

    Thank you for sharing. For standing up and explaining her why. She couldn’t leave because she couldn’t leave you.

  20. 20
    Natalia says:

    What a great story. I have such a similar story, except my father continues to live. He is much better now (or at least my mom tells me so), but I still am not sure I will truly ever love him or mourn his loss. I remember days wishing that he would die because I wanted my mom happy. Still to this day, as I have 4 children of my own, I wish my mother would leave my father so she could be free. She is the the wife of an alcoholic (though now sober for over 3 years). A therapist once told me that wives of alcoholics will never leave – they are in fact part of the problem themselves. They get something from being in that relationship – what my moms got/gets I will never understand. In my mothers eyes, there was always an excuse and it was always someone elses’ fault as to why my father overreacted (my fault, my brothers fault, her fault, the dogs fault). Excuses were always made and continue to be made. I digress though and take comfort in knowing that perhaps my children will not grow up in such an environment – but part of me wonders how much of that already exists because it is part of me.

  21. 21

    Niri – Thank you for sharing your powerful story of survival and strength. It’s so vivid – I felt like I was there with your 9 year old self – I can imagine to other victims of domestic abuse, hearing your story will be helpful – perhaps it will even inspire change. Thanks again.

  22. 22

    Oh Niri- I’m so incredibly proud of you for writing this. I can only imagine how challenging it was. Thank you for opening up yet another channel for discussion surrounding domestic violence. Through honest stories such as yours I have no doubt that others will gain strength and support. The more I learn about you the more I can truly say I’m honored to call you a friend.

  23. 23

    Thank you for sharing your story. I feel that there is a difference. Your mother had the incredible courage to try to leave in a cultural environment where that was unthinkable. I know so many cases of those who ended up committing suicide because they had nowhere to go. They were determined not to take the abuse even if it would cost them their life. I don’t think women are to blame for any abuse at all but Janay and many other women (and I know a few) CHOOSE to stay. There is absolutely nothing, NOTHING, I, you or anyone can do to make them leave. That’s why I feel this is the best tweet: “#WhyIStayed: You think you know but you have no idea”

    They don’t have an idea, how can we? All we can do is stay on the side and hope that they hit rock bottom before the abuse becomes fatal but I can tell you this: I know it’s not nearly as hard as taking the abuse but it’s nearly as painful staying on the side and watching a loved one going through it all without being able to lift one finger. That is why we ask that question, over and over and over and over again. It’s not to judge, we want to understand because maybe that can help us help you.

  24. 24
    Kristin says:

    No judgment…no pity…just sadness that women get hurt like this.

  25. 25

    This is so incredibly brave for you to share, and I can’t imagine how terrifying and confusing it was for you as a child. I’m sure you story has touched a chord with so many and maybe hearing the strength behind your words will help someone in a situation similar to your mother’s.

  26. 26
    Lillian says:

    Thank you for sharing your story.

  27. 27

    This is such a personal, powerful account, Niri, one that people who can’t relate to abuse REALLY need to read. You are so brave to share this. It’s not as easy to leave as many people seem to think it is. Thank you for this. xxoo

Leave a Reply